Librarian Woes

Welcome to a new thing! This may or may not become a reoccurring feature, but I wanted to get something off my chest. So here is a space for highlighting stuff librarians hate.

Yes. I am going to pretend that I speak for all librarians.

I bet in this instance I do.

My current librarian woe involves a new trend in book design. A lot (and I mean a lot) of publishers are now doing this thing with their hardcovers where the dust jacket is see-through and covers up some cool design printed on the cover of the book.

24331115 24189224 23395680 22693231

















(pictures don’t quite get the effect, but these are all recent overlay covers.)

Eyecatching? Maybe.

But when it comes to covering these suckers, I am losing my damn mind.

We have a book distributor that sends us our books already processed in plastic jackets. Occasionally certain books are not in plastic jackets, and usually that’s fine. It takes me like 30 seconds to pop on a cover protector.

Except with these damn books.

Because of the see-through designs, I can’t use our book jackets the way I am supposed to. They have white paper backings that cover up the whole book–not normally an issue with a regular dust jacket. But for these I have to tear away the white paper backing and work only with the plastic. Cumbersome, but okay, this is fine.

But then the damn white paper never comes completely off. It is impossible to get it all off. It leaves a really sloppy white border around the top of all of these books.

And then the covers don’t fit right anyway. Because the see-through plastic of the dust jackets is heavier, it doesn’t wrap around the book properly, and it doesn’t tape neatly either. It always bulges out in weird places.

So on the library shelves these books look cheap and messy, and I’ve torn out half of my hair to even get them to that state.

I can’t imagine them looking all that great on people’s shelves without plastic cover protectors, either. Because the dust jackets don’t fit. Hello, massive pet peeve of mine.

tl; dr: publishers, why are you doing this? Stop. This is a trend that needs to die.

(Counterpoint arguments? Is it possible that I don’t speak for all librarians? Let me know in the comments!)



Filed under Librarian Woes

2 responses to “Librarian Woes

  1. I’ve been thinking about this a lot too! I used to cover my book covers with plastic as well and that’s why I rarely buy hardcovers and prefer paperbacks. I like how creative publishers are getting, but looking at it from a librarian’s point of view, I understand why you disagree with their “creativity” 😀

    • hlmorris85

      Publishers are always trying to one-up each other on design, and maybe it’s a response to ebooks too, thinking people will more likely buy the hardcover if its fancy. But I’m thinking these things have to be massively expensive, and imo they don’t look all that great to start with.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s